Reflective Writing Assignment Quick Guide
STEP 1
Define the purpose
Make reflection meaningful, not just another task. A clear purpose helps students engage meaningfully and ensures the assignment supports your course goals. Without it, reflections may be vague, off-topic, or overly personal.
Make It Visible to Students: Explicitly connect reflection to course outcomes and real-world skills.
Choose the Focus: Course content, personal growth, study habits, professional goals, collaboration, etc.
Pick the Right Setting:
In-class, timed: Quick reactions.
At-home, open-ended: Deep synthesis.
Online journals: Ongoing engagement.
Handwritten: Personal, low-pressure.
Clarify the Learning Goal: Metacognition, critical thinking, self-awareness, real-world application, etc.
STEP 2
Translate purpose into practice
Aligning your assignment with students’ experience and classroom logistics ensures it’s doable and impactful. Without this step, students may struggle or disengage.
Match Student Experience:
Don’t assume they know how to reflect.
Use examples, sentence starters, and warm-ups.
Choose a Format:
Online, handwritten, embedded, or ongoing.
Plan Feedback:
Written comments, class-wide notes, peer review, or none (with transparency).
Set Assignment Value: Completion-based, rubric-based, or ungraded but required.
STEP 3
Scaffold and Support
Reflective writing is a skill, not an instinct. Scaffolding helps students build confidence and depth over time.
Frame It as a Skill:
Legitimize reflection like analysis or argument.
Teach Components:
Use frameworks (e.g., “What? So what? Now what?”).
Highlight description, analysis, connection, insight.
Practice Low-Stakes:
Start with journals, exit tickets, peer talks.
Reinforce Throughout: Revisit reflections, connect to content, share your own.
STEP 4
Plan for Grading
Grading reflective writing can be the most daunting part of the process. Clear expectations and thoughtful feedback help students grow and take the task seriously.
Plan Feedback: Decide type and be transparent.
Define What You’re Looking For: Insight, effort, relevance, growth.
Choose a Grading Approach: Completion, rubric, or ungraded.
Set Weight: Match the assignment’s importance.
Clarify Expectations: Use rubrics, examples, and criteria.
Feedback
Do you want to help us revolutionize teaching
and change how people learn?
Learn How
Prompts
UNIV 101
STEM
Grading
Rubrics
Why Reflective Writing?
Scholarship
For Students
BYU Humanities
2025 Ⓒ BYU Reflective Writing
Reflective Writing